|
|
Top 14 Special:
2010/11 Preview - Club by club guide to the new French season
By Colin Spiro, 12 August 2010
|

Can Clermont defend the title
they fought so long to attain?
Photo: Eoin Mundow/Cleva Media |
It may only be early August but the new
Top 14 season is almost upon us and 2010/11 promises to be
another roller-coaster ride for all those who follow the
French domestic scene.
Top 14 Fixtures 2010/11
Here at FRC we can't wait
for the action to begin - tomorrow (Friday) night - and to
help get everyone up to speed we've produced a club-by-club
guide charting recent form, squad changes and players to
watch.
The clubs are listed in the order they
finished in the league last season (hence Perpignan above
champions Clermont), with the Heineken Cup and Top 14 form
guides starting from 2010 and working back to 2005.
Hope that's all clear now here's the
guide...
Top 14 Transfers 2010/11
Top 14 Table 2009/10
Perpignan |
|
| In:
|
Romain Barriol, Kevin Boulogne,
Manny Edmonds, Julien Fritz |
| Out: |
Sebastien Chobet, Yannick Parent,
Nicolas Durand, Steve Meyer, Christophe Manas |
| Last five seasons Top 14: |
1st (r/up), 1st
(Champions), 4th, 5th, 4th |
| Last five seasons in HC: |
Pool stages, pool stages,
quarter-final, pool stages, quarter-final |
| Prospects: |
The 2008/9 French champions have
again been selective in their transfer activity as
they seek to build on the squad consistency which
has seen them finish first in Top 14 for the past
two seasons. The continuing lack of a top-quality
fly-half is their only obvious weakness, with
veteran Aussie Manny Edmonds pressed into emergency
service following his return from Bayonne on a
coaching basis. The 33-year-old has been granted a
three-month playing licence following yet another
injury to Nicolas Laharrague, with the No 10 berth
effectively being kept open for the anticipated
return of Dan Carter after the 2011 RWC. Consistency
has been their watchword over the past two
campaigns, with the Catalans likely to feature in
the top four again this season, especially if they
can maintain their superb home form at the Stade
Aimé Giral. President Paul Goze is desperate for a
serious run in the Heineken Cup, with the incentive
of switching a home quarter-final to Barcelona
should they progress that far. |
| Prediction: |
Play-offs, but no cigar |
| Man to watch: |
Kevin Boulogne |
Toulon |
|
| In:
|
Carl Hayman, Mehdi Merabet,
Jean-Philippe Genevois, Dean Schofield, Christophe
Samson, George Smith, Geoffroy Messina, Samy Ben
Letaief, Rachid Ahlalou, Paul Sackey, Rudi Wulf,
Thierry Brana, Benjamin Lapeyre |
| Out: |
Tim Ryan, Tonga Lea’aetoa,
Nicolas Agnesi, Esteban Lozada, Ross Skeate, Cedric
Beale, Conrad Barnard, Jamie Robinson, Sonny Bill
Williams, Tana Umaga, Luke Rooney, Phil Fitzgerald |
| Last five seasons Top 14: |
2nd, 9th,
ProD2, ProD2, 14th |
| Last five seasons in HC: |
Dnq, dnq, dnq, dnq, dnq |
| Prospects: |
The cash-rich Cote d’Azur club
has again been frenetic in the transfer market and,
like last season, their prospects will largely
depend on how well and how fast the new-look squad
gels. The addition of players such as Paul Sackey,
Carl Hayman and George Smith has undoubtedly
strengthened Philippe Saint-Andre’s squad, but the
loss of New Zealand centre Sonny Bill Williams is a
big blow. Saint-Andre and club president Mourad
Boudjellal were hugely disappointed not to round-off
2009/10 with a trophy, but Toulon should be stronger
for their double near miss last season. Winning Top
14 remains their main priority – and they now have
the squad depth to do so – but the
attraction/distraction of their inaugural campaign
in the Heineken Cup could either prove a hindrance
or a springboard to success. |
| Prediction: |
Champions |
| Man to watch: |
George Smith |
Clermont
Auvergne |
|
| In:
|
Ti’i Paulo, Sione Lauaki, Kini
Murimurivalu |
| Out: |
Benoit Cabello, Marco Ferrer,
Christophe Samson, Etienne Delangle, Sérémaia Bai,
Jeremy Malzieu |
| Last five seasons Top 14: |
3rd (Champions), 3rd
(r/up), 1st (r/up), 2nd
(r/up), 7th |
| Last five seasons in HC: |
Quarter-final, pool stages, pool
stages, dnq, pool stages |
| Prospects: |
Having finally lifted the
Bouclier de Brennus – at the 11th time of
asking – Clermont are likely to play with a greater
confidence and self-belief this season under the
wise tutelage of Kiwi coach Vern Cotter. As with
Stade Toulousain and Perpignan they have had only a
limited impact on the transfer market, but initial
impressions suggest powerful number eight Sione
Lauaki could be one of the buys of the summer. The
biggest problem Clermont could face is how quickly
they re-focus on this season’s demands after the
wild celebrations that greeted their final triumph
against Perpignan in May. If that frees them up to
play to their full potential then a second league
triumph and a serious run in the Heineken Cup could
yet be a serious prospect, but as Perpignan found
out last season it is one thing to win the title and
quite another to defend it. |
| Prediction: |
Play-offs and a decent Heineken
Cup challenge |
| Man to watch: |
Sione Lauaki |
Stade
Toulousain |
|
| In:
|
Sylvain Nicolas, Nicolas
Vergallo, Pierre-Gilles Lakafia |
| Out: |
Julien Le Devedec, Laurent
Thuéry, Quentin D’Aram de Valada, Manu Ahotaeiloa,
Jean-Baptiste Elissalde |
| Last five seasons Top 14: |
4th, 2nd, 2nd
(Champions), 3rd, 2nd (r/up) |
| Last five seasons in HC: |
Winners, Quarter-final, R/up,
Pool Stages, Quarter-final |
| Prospects: |
The elusive domestic and European
double may have slipped from their grasp last season
– when they lost in the Top 14 semi-finals – but the
vast strength in depth of Toulouse’s squad means
they will again compete on both stages in 2010/11.
Head coach Guy Noves has recruited shrewdly once
more with talented French youngsters Sylvain Nicolas
and Pierre-Gilles Lakafia being boosted by the
addition of Argentine scrum-half Nicolas Vergallo,
while big things will be expected of players such as
Yann David and Louis Picamoles after last year’s
settling in period. Jean-Baptiste Elissalde’s
retirement – to become backs coach – has left a
whole, but the signing of veteran Fijian winger
Vilimone Delasau at the tail end of last season
could yet prove inspired. |
| Prediction: |
Runners-up |
| Man to watch: |
Vilimone Delasau |
Castres |
|
| In:
|
Anton Peikrishvili, Gwendal
Lamanche, Benjamin Kayser, Vincent Colliat, Scott
Murray, Lucas Cazac, Jannie Bornman, Gambo Adamou,
Andrea Siccardi, Pierre Bernard, Sérémaia Bai,
Vincent Inigo, Romain Martial |
| Out: |
Fabio Staibano, Yohan Rayssac,
Marc-Antoine Rallier, Ludovic Michaux, Adrien
Foucras, Romain Boscus, Paul Bonnefond, Mathie
Bourret |
| Last five seasons Top 14: |
5th, 12th,
5th, 11th, 8th |
| Last five seasons in HC: |
Dnq, pool stages, dnq, pool
stages, pool stages |
| Prospects: |
Castres were one of the surprise packages of last
season as they improved their league position from
12th to fifth, but coaches Laurent Labit
and Laurent Travers have recruited widely in the
summer in an effort to build on that success. Again
they have concentrated in bringing in squad players
rather than star names, with the aim of improving
their talent pool so they don’t run out of steam
again at the season’s finale. The Heineken Cup will
be a welcome distraction, but Top 14 remains their
number one goal, with a top six finish their target
again. Are likely to be taken more seriously this
season after their fifth-placed finish, and will
once more seek to build on an impressive home record
at the Stade Pierre Antoine. |
| Prediction: |
Just missing out on play-offs |
| Man to watch: |
Chris Masoe |
Racing-Métro
92 |
|
| In:
|
Benjamin Sa, Julien
Brugnaut, Scott Zimmerman, Gregory Arganese, Karim
Ghezal, Antoine Battut, Nicolas Durand, Juan Martin
Hernandez, Albert Vuli Vuli, Benjamin Fall, Mirco
Bergamasco |
| Out: |
Clement Baiocco,
Mehdi Merabet, Craig Smith, Olivier Diomandé, Ashley
Clarke, Nic Berry, Fabien Fortassin, Epi Taione,
Sefulu Gaugau, Mani Vakaloa, Brent Ward, Andrew
Mehrtens |
| Last five seasons Top 14: |
6th,
ProD2, ProD2, ProD2, ProD2 |
| Last five seasons in HC: |
Dnq, dnq, dnq, dnq,
dnq |
| Prospects: |
By finishing sixth
last season – their first back in France’s top
flight - Racing confirmed they will be a force to be
reckoned with as long as head coach Pierre Berbizier
is backed by ambitious president (and
multi-millionaire) Jacky Lorenzetti. The latter’s
continued investment has enabled Berbizier to add
further quality to his already impressive squad,
with internationals Benjamin Fall, Nicolas Durand
and Mirco Bergamasco all joining up. But it is the
arrival of Argentine playmaker Juan Martin Hernandez
that could yet be the trigger for Parisian success,
although his impact could be dependent on how well
‘El Magico’ has recovered from the back surgery
which curtailed his efforts with Natal Sharks last
season. Like Toulon they make their debut in the
Heineken Cup this season, but league success remains
their top priority. Expect more of Springbok star
Francois Steyn after a settling-in season during
2009/10. |
| Prediction: |
Play-offs |
| Man to watch: |
Juan Martin Hernandez |
Biarritz
Olympique |
|
| In:
|
Sylvain Marconnet, Erik Lund,
Mathias Marie, Michael Bond, Dane Haylett-Petty |
| Out: |
Rémy Hughes, Mosese Moala, Cesar
Damiani, Trevor Hall, Fabien Cibray, Valentin
Courrent, Nicolas Brusque |
| Last five seasons Top 14: |
7th, 5th, 7th,
4th, 1st (Champions) |
| Last five seasons in HC: |
R/up, pool stages, pool stages,
quarter-final, R/up |
| Prospects: |
Inconsistency was Biarritz’s main
problem in 2009/10, but the club’s coaches have
largely shown faith in the squad which
underperformed in the league (finishing seventh) and
yet still reached the Heineken Cup final. President
Serge Blanco is urging a two-pronged attack for
silverware this season, but Biarritz still look
short of the depth in quality required for such
lofty ambitions. Last season their pack was the
foundation to their European success – backed by
electric three-quarters such as Takudzwa Ngwenya and
Iain Balshaw – but Toulouse’s forwards tore them
apart in the Heineken Cup final to expose crucial
weaknesses. Much is being made in France at present
of the club’s desire to play a more attack-oriented
game this season, but as ever their prospects are
likely to rest on the fitness of key players such as
Imanol Harinordoquy, Damien Traille and Dimitri
Yachvili. When those three play the Basques usually
emerge victorious. |
| Prediction: |
Play-offs, but no cigar |
| Man to watch: |
Damien Traille |
Stade
Francais |
|
| In:
|
Remy Bonfils, Dan
Wright, Gonzalo Tiesi, Martin Rodriguez Gurruchaga |
| Out: |
Sylvain Marconnet,
Benjamin Kayser, Pierre Vigouroux, Simon Taylor,
Charlie Davies, Mark Gasnier, Geoffroy Messina,
Mirco Bergamasco, Karl Pautric, Mathieu Blin |
| Last five seasons Top 14: |
8th, 3rd,
3rd, 1st (Champions), 3rd |
| Last five seasons in HC: |
Quarter-final, pool
stages, pool stages, quarter-final, pool stages |
| Prospects: |
2009/10 was quite
simply a horror season for the Paris club, with poor
results, a horror run of injuries, suspensions,
three changes of head coach and off-field financial
problems. The scale of their woes was highlighted by
their non-qualification for the Heineken Cup – an
absolute pre-requisite for a club of Stade Francais’
standing and ambitions. The arrival of former
Leinster boss Michael Cheika has shaken up the
current squad, and he will be desperately hoping
that he keeps key players such as new club captain
Sergio Parisse and French scrum-half Julien Dupuy
fit and available throughout the campaign. Their
presence in the Amlin Challenge Cup should allow him
time to rotate and rest key players, while British
imports James Haskell, Tom Palmer and Ollie Phillips
will be hoping to build on the favourable
impressions they made during a testing first season
in the French capital. |
| Prediction: |
Play-offs |
| Man to watch: |
Ollie Phillips |
Brive |
|
| In:
|
Pablo Cardinali,
Benoit Cabello, Vasil Kakovin, Julien Le Devedec,
Mathieu Belie, Regis Lespinas, Julien Caminati |
| Out: |
Jonathan Garcia,
Scott Zimmerman, Steve Thompson, Christian Short,
Arnaud Pic, Andy Goode, Lachlan MacKay, Riki Flutey,
Horacio Agulla |
| Last five seasons Top 14: |
9th, 6th,
11th, 10th, 10th |
| Last five seasons in HC: |
Pool stages, dnq,
dnq, dnq, dnq |
| Prospects: |
The 2010/11 season
will be one of re-adjustment for Brive, who have
down-sized considerably since the big-spending
sprees of 2008 and 2009. Brit imports Steve
Thompson, Riki Flutey and Andy Goode have all
departed as head coach Ugo Mola seeks a more French
feel to the Limousin club, and a season of
consolidation – with the outside aim of a top seven
finish – will be their target. Club finances and
squad numbers have both been trimmed, and surely
with that their ambitions too. A decent Amlin run
and strong home league form could be the key to
their fortunes this season, but avoiding involving
in a nasty relegation battle would probably be
viewed as success enough. Ex-England internationals
Jamie Noon and Shaun Perry both remain key figures
at the club after impressive first seasons –
especially from Noon – and the coaching staff will
also be hoping that influential Welsh No 8 Alix
Popham stays fit throughout. |
| Prediction: |
Missing out on
play-offs but possibly glory in the ACC |
| Man to watch: |
Alexis Palisson |
Montpellier |
|
| In:
|
Goderzi Shvelidze,
Giorgi Jgenti, Sebastien Chobet, Aliki Fakate,
Goncalo Uva, Raphael Lagarde, Santiago Fernandez,
Timoci Nagusa, Adrien Pratmarty, Seta Tuilevuka,
Dimitri Pelo, Robin Solano, Martin Bustos Moyano |
| Out: |
Bruce Douglas,
Philemon Toleafoa, Eugene van Staden, Alistair
Campbell, Benjamin Goze, Ollie Smith, Thierry Brana,
Manoël Dall’Inga, Federico Todeschini, Olivier
Sarraméa |
| Last five seasons Top 14: |
10th, 10th,
6th, 12th, 11th |
| Last five seasons in HC: |
Dnq, dnq, dnq, dnq,
dnq |
| Prospects: |
2010/11 is supposed
to be the season that Montpellier finally kick on -
from mid-table obscurity to top six contenders – but
off-the-pitch politicking is threatening to undo
their renowned stability. New head coach Fabien
Galthié knows that French internationals Fulgence
Ouedraogo and Francois Trinh-Duc are likely to
depart at the end of the season should Montpellier
fail to ignite, but the former Stade Francais boss
has brought in more than a dozen new faces as he
seeks to introduce a more hard-nosed approach to a
team typically strong at home but fragile on the
road. Former Albi boss Eric Béchu has been brought
on board – as forwards coach – but it remains to be
seen how quickly the new duo can implement their
game plans. |
| Prediction: |
Just doing enough to
stay clear of relegation |
| Man to watch: |
Timoci Nagusa |
Bourgoin |
|
| In:
|
Ruuan du Preez,
Jordan Merle, Julien Janaudy, Alex Tulou, Mickael
Campeggia, Nemani Nadolo, Brando Va'aulu, Sylver
Tian |
| Out: |
Pablo Cardinali,
Karena Wihongi, Jean-Philippe Genevois, Sylvain
Nicolas, John Senio, Benjamin Boyet, Albert Vuli
Vuli, Florian Denos |
| Last five seasons Top 14: |
11th, 11th,
10th, 6th, 6th |
| Last five seasons in HC: |
Dnq, dnq, pool
stages, pool stages, pool stages |
| Prospects: |
The club’s continuing financial struggles are again
threatening to undermine their on-field ambitions,
but if they can reproduce their battling spirit of
2009/10 then Bourgoin should be strong enough to
stay afloat. It remains a big ‘if’ though, with
several of their brightest young stars having been
picked off by the cream of French rugby once more.
Sylvain Nicolas (Toulouse), Jean-Philippe Genevois
(Toulon) and Albert Vuli Vuli (Racing) will all be
sorely missed, as will the reliable boot of
experienced fly-half Benjamin Boyet (Bayonne), but
Bourgoin look to have recruited soundly once more
and will battle for every point – providing they can
convince the DNACG of their financial viability and
unblock four player licences that are currently
being withheld. Survival alone will be their goal,
but as with the previous two seasons they will also
try and use the Amlin Challenge Cup as a springboard
for league success. |
| Prediction: |
Another season of
struggle, both on and off the pitch |
| Man to watch: |
Nemani Nadolo |
Bayonne |
|
| In:
|
Tonga Lea’aetoa,
Clement Baiocco, Emilien Attia, Walter Desmaison,
Cameron Treloar, Troy Flavell, Abdelatif Boutaty,
Julien Audy, Benjamin Boyet, Yoann Huget, Garth
Ziegler, Joe Pietersen, Sylvain Bouillon |
| Out: |
Salvatore Perugini,
Rodney Blake, Nicolas Laffite, Mikaera Tewhata,
Jaque Deen, Mickael Lopez, Benat Arrayet, Pierre
Bernard, Manny Edmonds, Vincent Inigo, Filimone
Bolavucu, Benjamin Fall |
| Last five seasons Top 14: |
13th, 7th,
9th, 8th, 12th |
| Last five seasons in HC: |
Dnq, dnq, dnq, dnq,
dnq |
| Prospects: |
Only Montauban’s financial woes prevented Bayonne
from slipping ingloriously into ProD2 last season,
but a major overhaul of the playing squad should
ensure there is no repeat of their 2009/10
struggles. Three of Montauban’s decimated squad now
find themselves in Bayonne’s colours for 2010/11,
and the acquisition of class acts such as former All
Black Troy Flavell and Bourgoin’s experienced
fly-half Benjamin Boyet gives the Basques not only
added quality, but also plenty of experience.
Bayonne still managed plenty of tries despite their
poor results last season – South African Sam Gerber
was the league’s top scorer with nine – but the loss
of Benjamin Fall to Racing is a blow. The Basques
need a solid start to help banish last season’s
demons, but should they manage that there is nothing
to stop them pushing for a top seven slot. |
| Prediction: |
Could be an outside
bet for seventh and the final Heineken Cup slot |
| Man to watch: |
Troy Flavell |
SU
Agen |
|
| In:
|
Karim Koulder,
Jean-Charles Pétin, Mosese Moala, Beka Sheklashvili,
Gert Muller, Brice Mach, Alejandro Campos, Maxime
Machenaud, Valentin Courrent, Jamie Robinson, Renaud
Dulin, Manu Ahotaeiloa, Miguel Avramovic, Kevin
Swiryn, Osea Kolinisau, Florent Cazeaux |
| Out: |
Thomas Synaeghel,
Anton Peikrishvili, David Te Moana, Max Carabignac,
Romain Sola, Yoann Huget, Sofiane Guitone, Francois
Gelez, Agustin Lopresti |
| Last five seasons Top 14: |
ProD2, ProD2, ProD2,
13th, 5th |
| Last five seasons in HC: |
Dnq, dnq, dnq, pool
stages, dnq |
| Prospects: |
Eight-time national champions SU Agen begin life
back in Top 14 this season with the solitary aim of
retaining their status come the end of the season.
To that end they have considerably bolstered the
squad which ran away with last season’s ProD2 title,
with 16 new faces brought in to give added quality
and experience. There is a truly cosmopolitan
flavour to Agen’s new-look squad and, as with
Toulon, it could be that their fortunes depend on
how quickly the fresh arrivals can bed-in. Success
would be Top 14 survival, although the club has much
grander plans for their long-term future. As with
any newly promoted team the other key to their
success, or failure, will be picking up as many
points as they can during the euphoric early season
before other teams begin to work them out. |
| Prediction: |
Survival - that's
what it's all about this season for Agen, and I
reckon they'll do it |
| Man to watch: |
Valentin Courrent |
La
Rochelle |
|
| In:
|
Jonathan Garcia,
Romain Sazy, Quentin D’Aram de Valada, Seru Rabeni,
Sefulu Gaugau, Manoël Dall'igna |
| Out: |
Clement Praud,
Mathieu De Pauw, Sebastien Morel |
| Last five seasons Top 14: |
ProD2, ProD2, ProD2,
ProD2, ProD2 |
| Last five seasons in HC: |
Dnq, dnq, dnq, dnq,
dnq |
| Prospects: |
It’s hard to see anything but a season-long struggle
for La Rochelle after the ‘Maritimers’ won belated
promotion via the ProD2 play-offs. Sensibly, given
their likely prospects, they have resisted the
temptation to over invest and stretch themselves
financially, preferring instead to largely keep
faith with the squad of players which got them into
Top 14. Like Albi last season they are unlikely to
trouble the many teams on their travels so it will
be essential for them to establish an
over-my-dead-body attitude when they welcome teams
to the Stade Marcel Deflandre. If that can be
achieved then they will have a fighting chance of
survival, but a budget of just €8m – a massive €9
less than Racing-Metro - underlines the degree to
which the odds will be stacked against them in
2010/11. Squad togetherness will be crucial, but
their limited resources are likely to be extended
beyond their bounds when the season hits the hard
yards around Christmas and the New Year. |
| Prediction: |
Enjoy it while you
can - straight back down for La Rochelle I'm afraid |
| Man to watch: |
Quentin D’Aram de
Valada |
|
|