We have discussed all-in-brawls,
eye massaging and ‘ball tampering’ and I have
hopefully dispelled a few myths and stereotypes. So
now is time for the long awaited conclusion, and it
is...
No. I don’t believe the French
deserve a reputation for foul play. They are
passionate and can occasionally show a willful
disregard for consequences, but they are no dirtier
than any other nation. Let me explain.
Rugby is a testosterone sport -
and I don’t mean that it is filled with performance
enhancing drugs.
Players spend the entire week
lifting weights and building towards the 80 minutes
that they will play on the weekend. Even non
professional players know the need to ‘psych up’
before a match. A quote from Vince Lombardi
relating to American Football is equally applicable
to rugby:
“Football is not a contact sport,
it’s a collision sport – dancing is a contact sport”
When a player knows that he is
about to have men the same size and bigger than him
literally collide with his body, there is a need to
get in the right headspace. This has been described
as “psyching up” but really it comes down to a
heightened aggression based on fear: Fear of being
hurt; Fear of losing; Fear of letting down your
teammates; Fear of being dominated by an opponent.
This aggression can lead to
punches being thrown, or any of the other offences
you occasionally see on a rugby pitch.
Personally, I don’t think the
occasional display of overt aggression is
particularly unexpected or anything to be ashamed
of. Drive into the centre of town on a Saturday
night and you’ll see plenty of examples of
heightened aggression.
Where we differ as rugby players
is in our respect for authority. Nine hundred and
ninety nine times out of 1,000 when the little man
with the whistle sternly waves a yellow piece of
cardboard in the air, you’ll see the offending
brutes - looking slightly abashed and chastened -
troop off to sit in the corner for 10 minutes.
The other crucial difference is
in our respect for each other. Rugby still has that
magic of sharing a drink after the game and grudging
approval, or unspoken acknowledgement, of your
opposite number’s abilities. If he got one over you,
it doesn’t make you want to find him in the car park
after the game. Just you, him and your crowbar
across his knees, that’ll teach him to step me...
Sorry. What was I saying again?
Foul play will always exist in
rugby – in every country and in every team. It is a
result of aggression and a passionate desire to win.
That the French have a reputation for some underhand
tactics is probably due to a couple of bad apples
and also because, as I have previously mentioned,
they don’t really seem to care too much about the
consequences.
Come to think about it……. rather
than a reputation for foul play, this lack of
respect for the consequences is what makes watching
the French and their ‘French flair’ so exciting.
Previous columns:
15.01.09:
Do the French deserve their reputation for foul
play? Part I
08.01.09:
Is professional rugby going to be credit
crunched?
18.12.08:
When two tribes go to war -
The local derby
11.12.08:
The
game they play in heaven, but who is playing God?
05.12.08:
The Unknown Soldier - Life
as a journeyman professional in France's ProD2