France’s home match against
Scotland on Saturday presents the perfect opportunity for
Marc Lièvremont's side to get back to winning ways after
their opening day defeat in Ireland.
The former French
flanker has been under increasing pressure since a
disappointing set of November internationals, but the
fluidity of some of the national team’s play against Ireland
hinted at a brighter future for Les Bleus.
Lièvremont is in that
tricky situation of trying to re-establish French flair
while at the same time satisfying critics with positive
results. To further complicate the formula he is also
endeavouring to bring through a raft of young talent that he
coached to victory in the 2006 Under-21 World Cup.
Ill-discipline – in the
shape of giving away needless penalties – cost France dear
against Ireland, and was symptomatic of the minor details
that make the difference between winning and losing with a
side in transition.
Against Australia in
November it was the wayward place-kicking of David Skrela
that let them down, but at least Lièvremont appears to have
solved that particular problem with the selection of Stade
Francais’ Lionel Beauxis at fly-half.
The 23-year-old had a
decent game against Ireland with his out of hand kicking and
general distribution, and also managed to land a tricky
conversion from the sidelines as well as two opportunistic
drop-goals.
He will resume his
half-back partnership with Sebastien Tillous-Borde but the
opportunity to feed an entirely Toulousain back-line has
been denied him by the citing and suspension of centre
Florian Fritz. In his place Lièvremont has brought in
another of his exciting young talents with Clermont’s Benoit
Baby (25) stepping up from the bench and leaving the coach
to rue Fritz’s actions.
“I am both disappointed
and relieved,” he said after the Toulouse centre had been
banned for three weeks, but cleared of eye gouging. “It will
serve as a lesson to Florian who is an aggressive player,
which is a good thing. But I think in rugby there is the
possibility within the rules to hurt your opponent,” he
reflected.
Elsewhere, Lièvremont
has tried to strengthen the under-performing second row by
dropping Sebastien Chabal to the bench and bringing in yet
another Toulousain – 25-year-old Romain Millo-Chluski. This
may be hard on Chabal – who Lièvremont appears to view as
more of an impact sub than a solid starter – as his second
row compatriot Lionel Nallet also had a disappointing match,
and has been struggling with his form for most of the
season.
The problem with axing
Nallet, of course, is that he is the French captain and
Lièvremont clearly has no intentions of going down that
route – not yet anyway. Nallet is the only player who has
started all of Lièvremont's matches since taking over as
France coach, and the sobriquet ‘special one’ may be apt in
this case.
Chabal, while accepting
his fate with dignity, is clearly unimpressed with his tag
as a ‘super-sub’.
“I have never
considered myself an ‘impact player’,” he said. “When I am
on the bench it is clear that I bring gas and penetrative
qualities when I come on. But when I start a match I am also
picked for the same reasons,” he added.
However, the Sale
player was quick to defend Lièvremont when asked about
France’s generally disappointing results this season.
“We have the means and the team to win games but we have
made a few mistakes in certain areas,” he said. “The team is
growing little by little. We are asking for time but it is a
while since we won an important match,” he admitted.
“I understand that the
public and the press are starting to become impatient but we
now where we are going,” he added.
Scotland have problems
of their own in the second row with Perpignan’s Nathan Hines
now likely to miss the entire Six Nations due to knee
surgery. Hines’ club colleague Chris Cusiter makes the bench
but Simon Taylor – who plays for Stade Francais – is in the
starting XV.
Scotland’s coach Frank
Hadden has also been under-fire this week following their
26-13 home defeat by Wales, primarily for the omission of
the Evans brothers (Thom and Max), which was seen as a
conservative selection.
Max underlined his own
credentials by coming off the bench to score a fine
individual try and Hadden has remedied his selection this
week with the inclusion of both.
The Toulouse players
will be only too aware of the pace these siblings can
provide following their shock home defeat to Glasgow in the
Heineken Cup, a fact acknowledged by Yannick Jauzion this
week.
“The Scots rely on
their opportunistic players and give their all in defence,
like all Gaelic teams. They have a lot of their players in
support who are capable of making a break at any time. They
are more attacking than the Irish and it will be up to us to
adapt,” said the experienced centre.
But, while the Toulouse
defeat should serve as a cautionary tale, there is no doubt
that Les Bleus will rightly start as favourites on Saturday,
especially as Scotland hasn’t won in France for a decade.
The Stade de France
will again demand beautiful flowing rugby, laden with
pitch-length sweeping moves that culminate in a glorious
tries – but a victory by any means will do for Lièvremont
right now.
Kick-off:
16.00
France:
C Poitrenaud (Toulouse); M Medard (Toulouse), B Baby
(Clermont Auvergne), Y Jauzion (Toulouse), C Heymans
(Toulouse); L Beauxis (Stade Francais), S Tillous-Borde
(Castres); F Barcella (Biarritz), D Szarzewski (Stade
Francais), N Mas (Perpignan), L Nallet (Castres, capt), R
Millo-Chluski (Toulouse), T Dusautoir (Toulouse), F
Ouedraogo (Montpellier), I Harinordoquy (Biarritz).
Replacements:
R Boyoud (Dax), B Kayser (Leicester), S Chabal (Sale
Sharks), L Picamoles (Montpellier), M Parra (Bourgoin), M
Mermoz (Perpignan), J Malzieu (Clermont Auvergne).
Scotland:
H Southwell (Edinburgh); S Danielli (Ulster), M Evans
(Glasgow), G Morrison (Glasgow), T Evans (Glasgow); P Godman
(Edinburgh), M Blair (Edinburgh, capt); A Jacobsen
(Edinburgh), R Ford (Edinburgh), A Dickinson (Gloucester), J
White (Sale Sharks), J Hamilton (Edinburgh), A Strokosch
(Gloucester), J Barclay (Glasgow), S Taylor (Stade
Francais).
Replacements:
D Hall (Glasgow), M Low (Glasgow), K Brown (Glasgow), S Gray
(Glasgow), C Cusiter (Perpignan), C Paterson (Edinburgh), N
De Luca (Edinburgh).
Referee:
George Clancy (Ireland).
Assistant
referees:
Wayne Barnes (England) and Tim Hayes (Wales)