"The whole point of rugby is that it is, first and foremost, a state of mind, a spirit" – Jean-Pierre Rives

Home | About Us | Contact Details | Sitemap  | Links 
 
 
French Rugby Club
Latest News
Features
Editor's Choice
Forum
Top 14
News
Results
Fixtures
Table
Top scorers
Transfers
History
Columnists
Ollie Phillips
Joe El-Abd
Paul Dearlove
Pro D2
News
Results & Fixtures
Top scorers
Transfers
Table
Heineken Cup
News
Results & Tables
Amlin Challenge Cup
News
Results & Tables
International
International News
Club Guide

   

Add to favourites!

Subscribe to French Rugby Club by Email

 

 

 

 

News: Stade president Guazzini claims Dupuy's ban is "political" and "anti-French"

19 December 2009

Stade Francais and France scrum-half Julien Dupuy
Banned: Stade Francais and
France scrum-half Julien Dupuy
Photo: Michael Paler

Stade Francais president Max Guazzini has labelled Julien Dupuy's six-month ban for eye-gouging as "excessive, very political and anti-French".

The flamboyant club owner hit out after the ERC disciplinary panel effectively ended Dupuy's season with the draconian ban. It is due to run until June 3rd, meaning the player - 26 today - will not be able to take any further part in Top 14 this season, and will also miss France's summer tour to the southern hemisphere.

Heineken Cup Pools & Fixtures

National coach Marc Lièvremont was also alarmed at the length of the ban, and urged Stade Francais to appeal to decision.

"We expected the worse and the worse thing has happened to Julien because six months is huge," said Lièvremont. "I hope there is an appeal and that the ban is replaced by something more reasonable," he added.

Guazzini, meanwhile, claimed there was anti-French bias to the ERC's decision, especially after Italy's Sergio Parisse - another Stade Francais player - and South Africa's Schalk Burger only received eight-week bans for eye-gouging offences during summer international games.

"The ERC wanted to make an example of a symbolic player of Stade Francais and of the French team which has never had a disciplinary problem," railed Guazzini. "It's not normal that a private organisation in Ireland prevents a club employee from working, from playing. It is we who pay him," he added.

That last quote shows that Guazzini has clearly allowed his anger to cloud his comments, but there's no doubt that the feeling in France is that Dupuy has been used as a high-profile casualty of the IRB's stated aim of cracking down on eye-gouging.

Perhaps the more pertinent question to ask is why do these incidents only ever hit the headlines in European club games, rather than in Top 14 matches? Is it a case of being ignored domestically but penalised by the larger rugby community?  

Sentencing on Dupuy's team-mate David Attoub, who was also cited for eye-gouging, was delayed on Friday until an unspecified date in the New Year. It is understood that the ERC disciplinary panel is seeking technical verification of a seemingly incriminating photograph that Stade now claim was 'doctored'. The photographer concerned, Olivier McVeigh, attended today's hearing in Dublin and denied any foul play, but the delay would seem to indicate that the panel want forensic confirmation before they pass judgement. Attoub is suspended in the meantime.

Dupuy knew that he faced a minimum of 12 weeks out but panel chairman Jeff Blackett decided his actions were serious enough to warrant the six month ban as the IRB continues its crackdown on eye-gouging.

The Stade pair released a statement of their own via the Stade Francais website earlier in the week as it became clear that television images were highly incriminating. The Paris club also apologised to Ulster for the duo's actions.

 

“The club deeply regret this situation,” said a Stade statement. “We envisage taking disciplinary sanctions against the players despite their citation before an ERC commission,” it added.

“It is normal that the club penalises players for actions as dumb and stupid,” said the Dupuy-Attoub statement. “Again, we apologise to the Ulster players and the club, whom we did not mean to cause offence. The actions were neither premeditated nor intentional.

“We want to apologise to our club, our staff and supporters for the negative image that we have left with these actions,” it added.

Television footage showed Dupuy twice putting his fingers into Ferris’ eyes. “I stupidly got riled up, like an idiot. I think my gesture came from irritation,” he admitted. “The images aren’t really in my favour, but I really didn’t want to put my fingers in his eyes,” added the former Leicester Tigers scrum-half.

London Wasps coach Shaun Edwards had led calls for a lengthy ban, with the former rugby league international describing eye-gouging as “the worst things you can do on a rugby field”. Edwards said he felt a year-long ban would be appropriate for the alleged offences.

 

 
 
Home | About Us | Privacy Policy | Contact Details | Sitemap  | Links 

© Copyright FrenchRugbyClub.com. All rights reserved.