|

Heineken Cup
Photo: Michael Paler |
Stade
Francais prop David Attoub has been hit with a massive 70-week
ban after being found guilty of eye-gouging by the ERC.
The huge
ban completely overshadows the 23-week ban handed down to team-mate Julien
Dupuy.
Both
incidents stem from the same match - Stade's Heineken Cup defeat away to
Ulster on December 12 2009. Dupuy and Attoub were found guilty of
eye-gouging Ulster's Stephen Ferris, but the latter's far heavier sanction
reflects his previous conviction for a similar offence, and also the fact
that he did not plead guilty after being charged.
Heineken Cup Pools & Fixtures
ERC
disciplinary officer Judge Jeff Blackett - who chaired both players'
hearings - described Attoub's offence as "the worst act of contact with the
eyes that I have had to deal with: it is a case of deliberate eye gouging."
Attoub
will now be ineligible to play again until April 22 2011, although Stade
Francais are bound to appeal the decision - as they did with Dupuy's.
Dupuy was
originally slapped with a 24-week ban, but that was reduced
by just one week on a technicality following the club's appeal.
Stade
Francais president Max Guazzini described Dupuy's original
ban as "anti-French" and "political", and he was no less
annoyed by the appeal decision.
"It is a
very heavy sanction. He [Ferris] said there was no gouging.
The fact that Dupuy is French probably played a role," he
said after Wednesday's hearing. And he also indicated that
the club will continue to fight the ban through France's
domestic governing bodies - the FFR and the LNR. "This
suspension is totally unjustified," he complained.
The
ERC's appeal committee, chaired by Professor Lorne Crerar
(of Scotland), made the one-week reduction after concluding
Dupuy "had demonstrated that the original decision been in
error only in a limited technical manner". An ERC statement
also confirmed that Dupuy's actions had been "at the top end
in the level of seriousness".
Dupuy,
26, will now be eligible to start playing again on May 27,
meaning he will miss the rest of the Top 14 season as well
the forthcoming Six Nations championship.
Attoub's original
hearing was delayed after questions were raised over the
authenticity of an incriminating photograph allegedly
capturing the incident. The ERC heard further evidence on
the matter on last Wednesday before finding him guilty of
the offence on Friday. "If it turns out to be an anti-sporting
offence the punishment will be announced at a later date,"
confirmed an ERC statement last week.